Manhattan Philosophy and Fries: Morally Wrong - Just an Opinion?

Mar 18 Thu 7:00 PM
Location

104 west 13 street
New York, NY 10011
212 741 0277

Attendance
 14  people attended.
4.00 4.003 (3 ratings)

Who organized?
Scott Stafiej

What do we mean when we say that something -- say, murder -- is "morally wrong"? While we will not limit our discussion to murder, the following questions encourage an exercise in thought:

Is "Murder is wrong" an empirical claim about the world? If so, how could we ever test it?

Is saying "murder is wrong" synonymous with saying "Murder makes people unhappy"? If that's the case, then how do we account for the fact that the statement "Murder is wrong" seems to be implying not just that murder makes people unhappy, but that there is necessarily something *bad* about making people unhappy?

If "murder is wrong" does not equate to "murder makes people unhappy", what are the differences between the two claims?

Does "Murder is wrong", a descriptive statement, translate into the prescription, "Don't murder!"? Or perhaps it's it an emotional reaction, meaning essentially "Boo murder!"

How could "Don't murder!" or "Boo murder!" ever be said to be true or false?

To stimulate discussion and to offer a common grounding, we have compiled the following readings. These are not required but they are encouraged in order to facilitate discussion. We look forward to seeing you there!

Readings:
http://plato.stanford...
http://en.wikipedia.o...
http://www.utilitaria...

This discussion will be facilitated by co-host of the New York City Skeptic's Rationally Speaking podcast, Julia Galef.

Discussion will be held at:

Salam Restaurant
104 west 13 street
(B/w 6th and 7th ave)
New York, NY 10011
[masked]

Trains Include: 14th st stops on the F,L, and V; also 1, 2, 3.

Photos of this Meetup

No photos yet.

Talk about this Meetup

  • You must be a member to post a comment. Join or login.

  • Scott K.
    Scott K.

    why the limit?

    Posted Mar 10, 2010 10:08 AM

Who attended?

Our Sponsors

Center For Inquiry

Become a Friend of the Center!

Other nearby
Meetups
Why these groups?
x

The Meetup Groups shown here are topically similar to Center for Inquiry | New York City.

Groups are more likely to be displayed here if they:

  • have a Meetup scheduled
  • have a high rating
  • have a group photo
  • are "public" and not "private"
  • have shown they are likely to stick around (older than 30 days)

Log in

  • Not registered with us yet?
or

Log in to Meetup with your Facebook account.

Sign up

or

Join this Meetup Group even quicker with your Facebook account.

By clicking the "Sign up using Facebook" or "Sign up" buttons above, you agree to Meetup's Terms of Service